Education
is Louisiana's top priority today! There is excitement, energy,
and hope about education in Louisiana, a state traditionally
ranked near the bottom of the 50 states on educational quality
and effectiveness. This state is also near the bottom on measures
of the wealth and health of its citizens, but a turnaround is
underway. Historically, one common perception of Louisiana has
been that of a state defined by opposites which often fall along
racial and socioeconomic lines: those who send their children
to private schools and those who cannot; those who are powerful
and those who are not; those who have professional careers and
those who have jobs in agriculture, the service sector, or the
oil industry. Today, however, people from these diverse groups
are working together to improve education by facing the challenges,
barriers, and inertia head-on.
Educational
leaders in Louisiana are taking an approach to reform that focuses
on the entire educational system to ensure that change takes
place in an integrated way, rather than progressing in a piecemeal
fashion. They are looking to the national reform movement for
guidance and support in improving the quality of education for
all students in the state. Teaching in Louisiana is expected
to improve as teachers are given more resources, responsibilities,
and opportunities to learn new skills. Students should have
improved educational experiences as problems throughout the
system are addressed. Let's look at how the story of education
in Louisiana unfolds.
Economic
Realities Lead to Support for Educational Reform
Economic
realities have helped mobilize the general public to support
educational reform in Louisiana. The oil and gas industry plays
a pivotal role in the state. Louisiana is the third largest
U.S. producer of oil and natural gas and is a center of petroleum
refining and petrochemical manufacturing. During the oil boom
of the 1970s and early 1980s, oil and gas accounted for 30 to
41 percent of the state's revenue, adding $1.6 billion to state
coffers in 1981-82. Times were good; there was little incentive
for the state to diversify its industrial base. However, what
was good for the state economy was not necessarily good for
public education.
The
ready availability of well-paying, low-skill roughneck jobs
in the oil patch reduced the incentive for many students to
complete high school. This attitude is often blamed for the
state's high literacy rate, low national test scores, and low
graduation rate (5). Those who controlled the purse strings
share a similar attitude toward investment in education; spending
for schools and teacher salaries in Louisiana was ranked lower
than nearly all of the 50 states. The oil industry has thus
been described as having a "profound impact on attitudes [of
policymakers, voters, and students] toward education" (5, p.
4).
This
history of low funding for public education has also been attributed
to the high rate of private and parochial school attendance
among the state's affluent and nonminority students. Many middle-
and upper-class families, including state decision makers, have
traditionally sent their children to these schools--it is a
way of life in Louisiana--and thus, had relatively little interest
in increasing financial support for public schools (7). Another
factor contributing to the traditionally low rate of spending
on education may be the large rural population in the state,
which is said to be leery of change in general and to have had
a limited interest in pursuing educational change.
During
the mid-1980s, oil prices declined. Oil companies reduced their
exploration and drilling activity and laid off workers. An economic
crisis resulted--high unemployment coupled with a poorly educated
workforce. The state's income from oil and gas plummeted and
has never recovered to boom levels. [In 1997, oil and gas revenues
contributed only 12% or $723 million of total state revenues.]
This situation changed the public view of education, as many
people realized that diversifying the state's economic base
was critical and that "a well-trained work force [was] the key
to attracting and maintaining new industry" (5, p. 5). Writing
in 1990 about the impact of this shift in attitude, education
leaders said, "change became inevitable--not merely tolerated,
but demanded . . . . The changing mood of the last decade, driven
by a deep economic crisis, has now created a consensus that
compels reform" (5, p. 5). The challenge was to find ways to
put more money into education--to go against the low priority
placed on school funding (1).
There
was a general economic upturn in the country during the mid-1990s.
Louisiana reported increases in available jobs in most sectors,
with decreased reliance on oil and gas. Unemployment dropped
from 13.1 percent in 1986 to 6.9 percent in 1995. The oil industry
stabilized, but at a lower production level and with fewer high-wage,
low-skill jobs (10). Despite the overall gains, Louisiana still
has one of the highest percentages of persons living in poverty
in the nation (19.7% for all persons and 31.0% for children
in 1995 [7, 10]). Related measures--the general health of the
population, rate of violent crime, infant mortality rate, and
child well-being--add to the picture of a state facing problems
on many fronts (6). Improving education is seen as a way to
change that picture.
Education
visionaries are beginning to convince citizens and policy makers
to improve the quality of education in the state by spending
more money on education. Economic realities have helped enlist
the support of the general public for reform, but questions
persist. What kinds of improvements should be made to the educational
system? How much will it cost? Where will the money come from?
As elsewhere, these are hot topics in Louisiana.
State
Population (1996)a |
4,350,579 |
Percentage
African-American |
31.6
|
Percentage
Hispanic |
2.4 |
|
|
No.
of school districtsb |
66 |
|
|
No.
of public schoolsb |
1459 |
Percentage
urban |
32 |
Percentage
suburban and large town |
19 |
Percentage
rural and small town |
49 |
|
|
No.
of public school students (1995-96)a |
767,796 |
|
|
No.
of private school students (12.1%)b |
105,688 |
|
|
Per
pupil spending (1996)b |
$4,194 |
U.S.
averageb |
$5,541 |
Louisiana
rankb |
45th |
The
Political Agenda Pushes Educational Reform
In
Louisiana, stories of power struggles between the governor,
legislature, state superintendent, state boards of education,
and teacher unions are common. A 1988 report on reform in Louisiana
concluded that, "Those who tried to change the system have time
and again seen reform measures watered down, ignored, not properly
implemented, taken to court by teacher unions, repealed, mired
down in turf battles and power struggles between public bodies,
or not funded" (3). This is changing as education leaders in
the state come together to solve the substantial problems facing
Louisiana education. Each successive governor has had his own
approach to educational issues, setting the tone for legislation.
Mike Foster, who took office in 1996, brought education to the
forefront. His agenda reflects national trends and includes
setting high academic standards, developing appropriate assessments,
establishing greater school accountability, increasing staff
development time, turning more control over to districts and
holding them accountable for results, making the charter-school
law less restrictive, and providing better preparation for children
to start school.
The
Board of Elementary and Secondary Education (BESE) has eight
elected members and three members appointed by the governor.
BESE supervises and controls the public elementary, secondary,
vocational, and special schools and has budgetary responsibility
for all state-appropriated school funds for K-12 schools. In
July 1999, control of vocational schools will be transferred
from BESE to the Board of Regents (BoR), which has responsibility
for higher education in the state. Prior to 1987, the state
superintendent of education was an elected official whose political
position on education was often at odds with those of BESE members.
In 1987, Louisianans voted to change the superintendency to
an appointed position, thus reducing some of the political tension
between BESE and the superintendent. A former state senator
and chairman of the Senate Education Committee, Cecil J. Picard,
was appointed superintendent by BESE in 1996. He heads the Louisiana
Department of Education (LDE) and is responsible for carrying
out BESE policies and laws affecting the public schools.
Today,
there is the sense that the governor, superintendent, legislators,
and board members are all on the same page, moving in the same
direction, to get Louisiana out of the basement with regard to
educational quality (7). Their commitment reflects the recent
history of educational reform in Louisiana that began with collaboration
to acquire federal grants and continues with a systemic approach
to improving education.