The teacher leadership literature offers more on the
idea of agency. In traditional settings, teachers are most often
cast in the role of managers, directing and controlling student
activities in the classroom, and following the rules set by the
administration (Suleiman & Moore, 1996). As a teacher moves out
of the managerial paradigm into an active leadership role, they
become decision-makers, planners, and collaborators who tend to
be more reflective, responsible, and empowered (Suleiman & Moore).
These authors stated that,
The teacher as a leader tends to be active and research-oriented
in the classroom. This provides teachers with the vehicle to put
them in charge of their craft and its improvement÷This alternative
construct views teachers as pivotal leaders in the schools as
agents of positive educational reform. (p. 10)
Teachers who are leaders in this sense have developed
agencythey believe that they have the power to act and that their
actions will have an impact.
Teachers' Sources of Authority
Teachers call on many sources of authority when making
decisiontextbooks, state and district policies, curriculum guides,
teaching manuals, university professors, and their own experience
in the classroom. Those who see their role as a manager tend to
follow the dictates of others (Suleiman and Moore, 1996); however,
recent literature emphasizes the importance of teachers using the
knowledge that comes from their own experience and that of colleagues.
TIMSS and other studies have described teachers in other countries
whose learning from one another by watching, discussing, reflecting,
trying new strategies, and so on, is built into the expectations
and structures of teaching.
"Teachers share knowledge and refine practice throughout
their careers" (Darling-Hammond, 1998, p. 10). In this country,
some kinds of opportunities for teachers to learn in communities
of their peers have led to improvement in practice as teachers build
their knowledge of practice and gain confidence to look to the authority
of that knowledge when making decisions. Darling-Hammond lists characteristics
of teacher learning opportunities that have this effect as being
experiential; grounded in teachers' questions, inquiry, and experimentation;
collaborative; connected to and derived from teachers' work with
students; sustained and intensive; and connected to other aspects
of school change.
Firestone and Pennell (1997) illustrate the relationship
between agency and authority in a study of two state-sponsored teacher
networks. The benefits of the networks were said to be increased
teacher learning, strengthened motivation, and enhanced empowerment.
The authors talked about empowerment.
The least controversial (and perhaps most significant) is the
enhanced sense of efficacy teachers develop in the classroom as
their content and pedagogical knowledge grows÷teachers may develop
a deeper knowledge of the theoretical and normative underpinnings
of the changes they make [so] there is a potential for an increased
sense of purpose÷.Networks may help teachers voice their informed
dissent from the "knowledge" of experts and the policies of those
in positions of authority. (p. 239, 240)
Thus, as teachers learn more about content, pedagogy,
and reform, they develop confidence in their own authority as they
advance their views of good practice.
|